That's the buzz concept, right?
"It's not a diet, it's a lifestyle"
Buckle in for this blog post because there is so much I want to say and I just hope that I'm not all over the place.
When I was looking for images to put in this post I came across this one which came from
this site. This article is definitely one of the better ones regarding making a lifestyle change as opposed to dieting, but I still have my own opinions about this whole idea of making a lifestyle change.
Is there anyone else out there who feels like the pressure of making a "permanent lifestyle change" is overwhelming? Do you feel like when people suggest you make a lifestyle change that means you should be "perfect" all the time and just all of the sudden want to make the healthiest of all choices? No? That's just me? Because it has taken me years to realize that calling it a lifestyle change did more damage to me than not labeling it as anything. You can look back through my blog posts and I'll say diet, lifestyle change or whatever you want to call this. I stopped trying to label it because the fact of the matter is it's just my journey.
The article that I linked above broke down the difference between a lifestyle change and a diet. Some of the things that defined a diet in the article were: weight is generally lost quickly over a set period of time, foods are characterized as good or bad, calories are greatly restricted, etc. The things that defined a lifestyle change were: eating healthy, nutritious foods to nourish your body; practicing moderation, not restriction; losing weight at a safe and healthy pace (1-2 pounds per week).
Here's my problem with this. If it were easy for me to eat healthy, nutritious foods to nourish my body and practice moderation than I wouldn't be here in the first place. And, telling someone like me that my lifestyle should now focus on eating foods that nourish my body; I interpret that as having to only choose nutritious foods and I'm not doing well if I choose foods that aren't as nutritious. Don't get me wrong; I understand that the idea behind a lifestyle change is that you don't have to be perfect. But when someone tells me I have to change my entire lifestyle I see that as an overwhelming change to make.
This same article had this graphic to depict why dieting is so unsuccessful.
I don't disagree with this cycle, but let's talk about what happens when you go through the diet cycle, but never give up. What happens is that over time you will find that you have slowly but surely made that "lifestyle change". You'll find that the deprivation feeling isn't as serious or takes longer to surface. You'll find that those cravings become less severe (but, you probably will always have cravings and it's OK). You will also get to a point where it's not so much about "giving in, feeling guilty and starting over"; as it is about taking a break, not feeling any guilt (or trying really hard not to feel any guilt because there's nothing to feel guilty about), but then refocusing on your goals. You may also find that in the process of starting that diet you have made a habit of working out and that continues regardless of what is happening with your food choices. Why does no one talk about the fact that you may have to "diet" in order to figure out what that lifestyle looks like for you?
Listen; you have to have a calorie deficit in order to lose weight. I don't care if you're eating the most nutritious foods there are; if you eat more calories than you burn you will not lose weight. When I see things that say it's not so much about the calories as it is about the type of food I want to scream. Again, I understand the point that is trying to be made. But, I really feel like the people who try to make those points are not people who have struggled with food in their own lives. Yes; your body will respond to 1000 calories of broccoli differently than it will to 1000 calories of gummy bears, but you can still lose weight if you eat less calories than you burn regardless of where those calories come from.
Stay with me because I think people are going to disagree with that statement.
Obviously losing weight is easier when you choose foods that have a lot of nutritional value. The physical aspect of losing weight is easier when you eat 1500 calories worth of fruits, veggies, lean meats, etc. But I think it's important for people to hear that the weight will still come off if you have a day (or a week or a month) where you fill those 1500 calories with less than stellar food choices. Sometimes the only way to teach someone moderation (and, let me tell you, if someone is trying to lose weight chances are they need to be taught moderation and can't just be told to "eat in moderation"), is to track and count your calories regardless of where those calories come from.
It has taken me years to come to this conclusion and yet I still struggle with all of it. I struggle with wanting to eat for absolutely no reason. I struggle with feeling like what I've done is not good enough because I will periodically have days where all my calories come from crap foods. I struggle with feeling like I "should" have lost more body fat in those 16 weeks. But that's bullshit. Could I have lost more body fat in those 16 weeks? Absolutely. I could have completely restricted my calories the way I did during that last week. I could have made sure to only eat those super healthy, nutritious foods and cut things like carbs and sweets out; but for me that would not be a realistic lifestyle change.
Even with allowing myself to eat basically whatever I want as long as I keep it within my calorie range; I struggle with wanting to just eat without thinking (which almost always means eating crap food and more calories than I burn). So you know what I do? Sometimes I just let myself have that time. Years ago that meant months of eating that way and gaining back weight. But now it usually means a few days and then I realize there's really no reason for that so I go back to tracking and staying in my calorie range. My hope is that these changes continue to happen.
Even last year I stopped losing weight between May and the end of the year. But the difference was that I kept doing just enough so that I had only gained about 5 pounds during that time. Not to mention the fact that I broke my wrist in July and didn't let that stop my activity level. My hope is this year I do a little better. That's it. I don't have to be perfect. I don't have to hit my goal weight in 2019. I don't have to lose weight every single month this year in order to feel good. What I have done has resulted in me losing 75 pounds and I am still going. This is my lifestyle change. This is something that I can see myself doing indefinitely. And that is what makes it the right thing for me. So remember, in order to be successful in weight loss you have to find what works for you!
This is a reminder to myself; but also, if even one person reads this post and something clicks in their brain to help them on their journey I will be happy. And this was a long one so if you're still reading, thanks 😊